Editorial transparency and use of artificial intelligence
This article forms part of the CostaLuz Lawyers blog and is published for general informational and educational purposes only. It was prepared with the assistance of artificial intelligence tools and, before publication, was substantively reviewed and editorially approved by Maria de Castro, a Spanish-qualified lawyer registered with the Cádiz Bar Association under number 2745, founder of CostaLuz Lawyers and the person responsible for the editorial review of the published content.
This article does not constitute legal, tax, immigration, employment, estate-planning or investment advice and does not replace an individual assessment and the professional work of the appropriate CostaLuz Lawyers specialist. No action or omission should be based solely on this information.
The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has ruled that mortgage opening fees are abusive when transparency requirements are not met.
According to the ruling, national judges must ensure that the borrower can evaluate the economic consequences of the clause, understand the nature of the services provided in exchange for the expected expenses and verify that there is no overlap between the different costs or services they retribute.
The ECJ decision leaves the door open for judges to evaluate whether the borrower when signing such a clause, was in a position to know the economic consequences, as well as the nature of the services that the financial institution claims are provided and that justify its charge.
It must also be verified that there is no duplication or overlap of the different expenses contained in the contract.
The Supreme Court in Spain is expected to clarify how it will apply this ruling, as it contradicts its previous decisions.
Mortgage opening fees are the amount banks charge to formalize a loan, with the justification being to cover the administrative and management costs of the loan. The rationale for the charge must be for specific, real services that are accepted or requested by the banking client and provided by the entity.
Typically, the commission clauses can be found in the fourth clause of mortgage contracts that detail the different commissions that the financial institution may receive during the mortgage term. For example, if the requested loan amount were €100,000, the amount payable for the opening commission, according to the above-mentioned 0.75% example, would be €750.
In Spain, it remains to be seen how this ruling will affect mortgage contracts and whether borrowers will have grounds to reclaim these fees. Therefore, it is recommended that borrowers seek legal advice before making any claims.
Mortgage holder in Spain? Your mortgage may contain abusive clauses (floor clause, IRPH, excessive expenses, early maturity). CostaLuz offers a free mortgage review to check if you are entitled to a refund.
Legal Notice: The content on this page is provided for general informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. No action should be taken based solely on this content without first seeking independent professional legal counsel. Each case requires individual assessment based on its specific circumstances. CostaLuz Lawyers accepts no liability for actions taken or not taken based on this content.
Buying or selling property in Spain?
We protect both sides of your Spanish property transaction from offer to deed. Bilingual help across southern Spain since 2006.